Behaviorism, though a very old theory of learning, has positive impact on education even today. Many psychologists have debated against the assumptions of this theory, but it still stands today as one of the main theories used to guide classroom instructions. Standridge (2002) asserts that behaviourism has frequently been used in the education sector to foster appropriate and desired behavior while discouraging those deemed unacceptable.
Reinforcing Effort
Pittler, Hubbell, Kuhn & Malenoski (2007) proposed various strategies that are effective in helping students to acquire, integrate, review and apply learning. Two of the strategies outlined by them are homework and practice and reinforcing effort. Both strategies have behaviorist principles embedded in them. Behaviorists argue that learners acquire behaviour, skills and knowledge in response to rewards, punishment or withheld responses (reinforcement) associated with them (Lever Duffy & McDonald, 2008). Pittler, et. al. (2007) suggest that the instructional strategy of reinforcing effort enhances relationship between effort and achievement by addressing students’ attitudes and beliefs about learning. This strategy intends for students to respond to the results from their effort/achievement chart or graph (stimulus) and thereby make the necessary changes by adjusting their effort (behavior) so that achievement can be improved. The teacher is expected to offer support, guidance and motivation to the students as they progressed through the assessment of their effort and achievement. Based on the results garnered, the students are expected to set objectives to improve in weak areas.
Homework and Practice
Pittler et. al. (2007) postulate that homework and practice provide opportunity for students to deepen their understanding of content and gain proficiency with their skills. From the findings of the McREL research, it was recommended that educators establish a homework policy. The establishment of these policies support the behaviourist strategies of contract which Orey (2001) states are effective in helping students focus on a behaviour change. The use of homework and practice is also expected to sharpen students’ skills and the repetitive nature of these activities support the behaviourist principle that repetition plays an important role in the learning process. Programmed instruction (drill and practice) through software or other web resources is very effective in the process of practicing as it offers the students the opportunity to carry out various tasks until they have achieved mastery. Feedback which is an important component of behaviourism is immediate and personal. Smith (1999) cited Hartley (1998) suggestion of the four principles that make up the behaviorist learning theory. He pointed out that one of the principles is that clear objectives and expectation assist students within the learning process. McREL researchers recommend that homework should be designed so that they clearly articulate purpose and outcome. This will inturn foster the achievement of the desired behaviour.
Overall, it is clear that these strategies bring out various behavorist principles that have been reaping great success in the learning environment. The advancement of technology has also made the implementation of these strategies more effective. It is therefore the teacher’s responsibility to constantly assess the effectiveness of these strategies on each group of students and determine the modifications to be made. In my teaching experience I find homework and practice to be very effective. I have always tried to encourage my students to work harder as this will bring them greater success but I have never utilized the tools such as charting and graphing of students progress. I intend to try these strategies to see the effect they will have on my students.
References
Lever-Duffy, J., & McDonald, J. (2008). Theoretical foundations (Laureate Education, Inc., custom ed.). Boston, MA: Pearson Education, Inc.
Pitler, H., Hubbell, E., Kuhn, M., & Malenoski K., (2007).Using technology with classroom instruction that works. Alexandria, VA: Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development.
Smith, K. (1999). The behaviourist orientation to learning. In The encyclopedia of informal education. Retrieved from http://www.infed.org/biblio/learning-behavourist.htm
Smith, K. (1999). The behaviourist orientation to learning. In The encyclopedia of informal education. Retrieved from http://www.infed.org/biblio/learning-behavourist.htm
Standridge, M. (2002). Behaviorism. In M. Orey (Ed.), Emerging Perspectives on Learning, Teaching, and Technology. Retrieved November 6, 2010, from http://projects.coe.uga.edu/epltt/index.php?title=Behaviorism
I am so glad that you talk about the fact that our students need to have clear expectations. So many time teachers forget that students cannot meet our expectations if we do not make them clear. How is a student to master content if we don't state our expectations or objectives and make sure they understand them?
ReplyDeleteHello,
ReplyDeleteI haven't tried the charting, graphing, etc. with my students either to have them see their own progress, but I have began keeping track of student participation in class in response to some behaviorist ideas. For example, I am making the assumption that if I continuously and positively reinforce every student’s participation in class they will be more inclined to do so in the future. I am keeping track of their participation in regards to my attempts at the former. What I am finding is that it is much harder to do than I thought it would be at the outset.
I hope by the end of this year to have an effective method in place.
Good luck with your efforts too.
Janice,
ReplyDeleteI think homework and practice can be effective if utilized properly. My outlook on homework has changed since I began teaching, especially because I teach social studies. I have lessened the amount of homework I assign because I felt that some of the assignemnts I gave were not necessarily meaningful. I try to be very careful when assigning homework now and only assign it if I feel it truly reinforces an important concept. I will not assign homework just for the sake of giving homework. To me, math is the subject in which students most benefit from frequent homework assignments. It is the sujbect that requires the most practice in order for students to master a concept. I still think homework can have a place in all content areas, but I strongly believe teachers must carefully consider WHY they are assigning the homework and whether or not it will truly benefit their students.
Janice,
ReplyDeleteI agree with you that homework is important. I know that some people are aghast to learn that students have homework as early as 2nd or 3rd grade, but I think that it is important to teach our students responsibility in this way. Additionally, when young children are learning basic skills they need as much reinforcement as they can get, both at school and at home. In my class, my students have a small amount of homework every night to practice those basic skills and responsibility. They are required to read or be read to for 15 minutes each night. I think this is something that parents should be doing without being told, but it is surprising how many view it as an unnecessary chore!
-Krista Zade
Hi Kristy
ReplyDeleteThank you for your reply. I really see the need to ensure that students understand clearly what they are expected to do. I think all teachers should reflect on their journey as a student and remember the challenges we had when we were not clear how an assignment should be done. I also remember one year I gave my students an assignment but I did not spend much time to discuss the assignment. I found many students coming to me saying they were unable to do the assignment and how hard it was. I then explained the expectations to each group and they were able to do well on the assignment. What I found out then was that if I had spent more time in class to explain the assignment, it would have taken less time and energy to state the expecation and the students would have been more confident in completing the assigned task. Each year as we do our plan, we need to set one objective to ensure that our students clearly understand what they are expected to do in assigned tasks.
Hi Jonathon
ReplyDeleteThanks for your reply. You mentioned that you keep track of your students' participation in class, do you provide them with frequent update based on your findings? If so, how do they respond to the results?
Hi Andrea
ReplyDeleteOf a fact home should not not be given for the sake of giving an assignment. Marzo, Pickering & Pollack (2001) assert that there should be a purpose for giving homework and these homework must be meaningful. When we simply give assignments without meaning we often falter in the process of providing feedback because we too do not attach any level of priority to the entire process. Because I feel that students need practice in order to better master content and often homework provides the best avenue for this to take place, I suggest that we rethink the kind of assignments we give and ensure that they do not simply repeat what was done in class, but are so structures that studenta can discover knowledge and even create knowledge in the process. This might be the best approach for Social Studies.
Reference
Marzo R. J., Pickering D. J. & Pollock J. E. (2001). Classroom Instruction that works: Research based strategies for increasing student achieving. Alexandria, VA: Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development.
Hi Krista
ReplyDeleteResearch conducted by Marzo, Pickering Pollack (2001) have concluded that homework is not very effective at the early grades. I however believe that it is more about the quantity and quality of work that we give to students at this level. Like you suggest that every night you give students a little bit to do so they can practice basic skills. This is very important because the activity serves as a great source of reinforcing concepts while promoting keen sense of responsibility as the students grow and develop. If you find that it is working for your students continiue to do it. Theories serve as guides but do not dictate what goes on in your classroom.
I find that it is through home work that I recognize when I truly understand or do not understand a concept. Often I have been in classes and I feel that I have learnt all that was taught but at the point when I tried to complete my assignment I recognize that I missed an important point. I use my homework to cement concepts and to identify challenges.
I agree that homework should not always simply repeat what was covered in class. I try to assign things that extend their thinking and force them to think more critically about a topic introduced in class. I think this is extremely important in social studies. They need to make connections between the material we are studying and what they are already familiar with.
ReplyDeleteDoes anyone here offer any rewards or punishments when dealing with homework? Last year I offered my students $100 a week in their bank accounts if they completed every homework assignment without handing it in late or needing to go to their locker to get it. I felt that that kept students motivated to do their homework more. Once I began doing that I did have a better understand of material in my math class.
ReplyDeleteHi Jillian
ReplyDeleteI do offer rewards or punishment when dealing with assignment but they are specifically related to grades. I assign grades for timeliness in handing in assignment and also presentation. When these are not up to standard, then marks are deducted. For example I take away 5 points from each day that the assignment is late and after three to five days late (depending on the type of assignment)the assignment will not be accepted. I avoid using money or other kinds as reward for students on a regular basis because I feel they will use whatever means possible to get the assignment done simply because they are motivated by the money and not the quality work produced or grades obtained. I do have time when I give gifts to my students for their outstanding performance but I do not use money as a means of motivation.